Understanding the Key Differences in Public vs. Private Construction Contracts

By AIA Contract Documents

March 1, 2024

Construction projects, whether public or private, involve complex contractual agreements that govern the rights and responsibilities of all parties involved. However, there are significant distinctions between contracts for public projects and those for private projects. Understanding these differences is crucial for contractors, subcontractors, and other stakeholders to navigate the intricacies of each type of project. Let’s explore the key disparities in construction contracts between public and private projects:

Procurement Process:

Public Projects: Public projects typically involve a competitive bidding process, where contractors submit sealed bids in response to a solicitation from a government agency or entity. The contract is awarded to the lowest responsive and responsible bidder, following specific procurement regulations.

Private Projects: In contrast, private projects often involve negotiated contracts between the project owner and the contractor. The selection process may be based on qualifications, reputation, or previous working relationships rather than solely on the lowest bid.

Contractual Requirements:

Public Projects: Contracts for public projects are subject to stringent regulations and compliance requirements, often mandated by federal, state, or local laws. These contracts may include provisions related to prevailing wage rates, minority business enterprise (MBE) participation goals, bonding requirements, and specific insurance coverage.

Private Projects: Contracts for private projects offer more flexibility and customization. While they may still include certain legal requirements, such as adherence to building codes and zoning regulations, private contracts are typically less encumbered by government-mandated provisions.

Payment Terms:

Public Projects: Payment processes in public contracts are often governed by strict procedures to ensure transparency and accountability. Payment schedules may be tied to project milestones, and contractors may be required to submit certified payroll reports to verify compliance with prevailing wage laws.

Private Projects: Payment terms in private contracts can vary widely and are often negotiated between the parties involved. Payment schedules may be based on progress billing, lump-sum payments, or other arrangements agreed upon in the contract.

Dispute Resolution Mechanisms:

Public Projects: Dispute resolution procedures for public contracts are often governed by specific laws or regulations, which may require mediation, arbitration, or litigation through administrative channels or the court system. Contractors must adhere to strict timelines and procedures for filing claims or disputes.

Private Projects: Dispute resolution mechanisms in private contracts can be more flexible and may include provisions for negotiation, mediation, arbitration, or litigation, depending on the preferences of the parties involved. Private contracts may also include provisions for alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods, such as dispute review boards or partnering agreements.

Risk Allocation:

Public Projects: Risk allocation in public contracts may be influenced by statutory limitations and requirements. Government agencies often seek to allocate risks to contractors to ensure project performance and protect public funds.

Private Projects: Risk allocation in private contracts is subject to negotiation between the parties, allowing for more flexibility in distributing risks associated with design changes, delays, unforeseen conditions, and other factors.

In conclusion, while construction contracts for public and private projects share some similarities, they also exhibit significant differences in procurement processes, contractual requirements, payment terms, dispute resolution mechanisms, and risk allocation. Contractors and stakeholders must carefully consider these distinctions when engaging in either type of project to ensure compliance with applicable laws and regulations and to effectively manage risks and responsibilities.

AIA Contract Documents software allows you to efficiently create, share, and manage the industry’s leading construction documents. Request an ACD5 Product Demo Here.

AIA Contract Documents has provided this article for general informational purposes only. The information provided is not legal opinion or legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship of any kind. This article is also not intended to provide guidance as to how project parties should interpret their specific contracts or resolve contract disputes, as those decisions will need to be made in consultation with legal counsel, insurance counsel, and other professionals, and based upon a multitude of factors.