Access the A201®–2017
To purchase a one-time use license for this document, visit the link below:
A201®–2017, General Conditions of the Contract for Construction
Interested in getting unlimited access to our full 250+ library of agreements and forms?
Visit the link to learn more: https://shop.aiacontracts.com/unlimited-subscription
March 21, 2023
A mutual waiver of consequential damages is a commonly included provision in construction contracts, especially in the AIA Contract Documents, including the A201-2017, General Conditions of the Contract for Construction. This waiver is important because it helps reduce uncertainty surrounding claims for indirect losses, which can be difficult to prove and quantify. However, the concept of “consequential damages” is not always immediately clear to all parties involved, making it an important topic during contract negotiations.
What Are Consequential Damages in Construction Contracts?
Consequential damages refer to indirect losses that result from a breach of contract. These damages are often beyond the immediate scope of the breach and can include:
- Lost profits – Financial losses due to disruptions in business operations.
- Damaged reputation – Negative impacts on a company’s public image.
- Loss of business opportunities – Missed chances for contracts, deals, or partnerships.
- Loss of use – When assets or equipment become unavailable due to the breach.
In some cases, the classification of damages as consequential can vary depending on jurisdiction. For example, some jurisdictions may consider losses that are entirely unrelated to the contract as consequential damages, while others may categorize them as direct damages, such as delays or replacement costs, depending on the situation.
Why Contractors Waive Consequential Damages in Their Agreements
Waiving consequential damages is often a strategic decision in construction contracts. This waiver serves several purposes:
- Clarity and certainty: It removes the uncertainty that comes with claims for consequential damages, which can be difficult to define and establish.
- Reduced legal challenges: Proving the direct link between a breach and consequential damages can be a complex and costly process. A waiver minimizes the legal resources needed to establish entitlement.
- Risk management: By mutually waiving these damages, both parties agree not to pursue claims for indirect losses, focusing instead on more direct damages like repair or replacement costs.
Legal Implications of Waiving Consequential Damages
The waiver of consequential damages impacts both parties involved in the contract. By including this provision, you agree that if a claim arises for consequential damages, neither party will pursue a claim for these damages. Instead, only direct damages, such as repair costs or replacement costs, are recoverable. This decision is often made to streamline the legal process and prevent disputes that may be challenging to resolve.
How the AIA Contract Documents Address Consequential Damages
In the AIA Contract Documents, including the A201-2017, the mutual waiver of consequential damages is clearly outlined. This clause is part of the broader legal framework that governs construction contracts, and its inclusion helps maintain fairness between the contracting parties. The AIA’s approach helps standardize the process and ensures that both parties understand the limitations of their rights to claim damages.
Best Practices for Addressing Consequential Damages in Contracts
To avoid confusion or potential conflict later in the project, it’s wise to define what constitutes consequential damages in the contract. You might consider specifying certain types of damages that are excluded from the waiver or providing clear definitions. Additionally, a mutual waiver should be carefully negotiated and agreed upon by both parties to ensure that all risks are properly managed and understood.
Conclusion
By understanding and agreeing to a mutual waiver of consequential damages in your construction contracts, you protect yourself and your counterparty from the complexities and uncertainties of proving indirect losses. It allows both parties to focus on direct, tangible damages that are easier to quantify and resolve. If you’re drafting or reviewing a construction contract, consider including this provision to streamline the process and safeguard both parties from unnecessary legal challenges.
AIA Contract Documents has provided this article for general informational purposes only. The information provided is not legal opinion or legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship of any kind. This article is also not intended to provide guidance as to how project parties should interpret their specific contracts or resolve contract disputes, as those decisions will need to be made in consultation with legal counsel, insurance counsel, and other professionals, and based upon a multitude of factors.