A negotiated “as is” clause can limit the claims available to a buyer after construction defects surface. In Passco Companies, LLC v. Rim WP Apts, LLC, the Texas Business Court enforced a disclaimer of reliance and dismissed several claims involving water intrusion discovered after the sale of an apartment complex.
The practical takeaway for architecture, engineering, and construction teams is that post-construction risk depends on more than the condition of the property. The purchase agreement, sub-management contract, due diligence record, and construction contracts and warranties that transfer with or survive the sale can all affect the parties’ rights.
The Purchase Agreement Defined Permitted Reliance
A San Antonio apartment complex was completed in 2018 and sold to Passco in 2019 following a due diligence period. In 2021, Passco discovered severe water penetration. Its experts attributed the damage to building envelope defects involving water-resistive barriers, perimeter sealing, and roofing membranes. Based on the issues present, they asserted that the developer knew what was going on with the building before transferring ownership.
Passco sued the seller, developer, property manager, and related individuals for breach of contract and brought fraud claims, arguing that the developer made false representations to induce them into the sale. The defendants asked the trial court to resolve several claims before trial via summary judgment, arguing, among other things, that they disclaimed reliance on the representations and warranties and were selling “as is.”
The court found that Passco was a sophisticated buyer, had legal representation, and had negotiated a clear disclaimer of reliance. The provision barred Passco from relying on statements outside the purchase agreement, including a pre-sale questionnaire about the building envelope (upon which the fraud claims partially relied).
One representation within the purchase agreement fell outside the disclaimer, but the court found no evidence that it was false. The court granted partial summary judgment on most of the fraud and breach claims against the moving defendants. The ruling wasn’t a final judgment, and some claims against the seller remained pending.
Build a Transfer Package for the Property
Owner-developers and buyers should determine which facts require express representations in the purchase agreement and how long those representations will survive closing. Even more importantly, they should review disclaimers and take special care around the phrase “as is.” Additionally, provisions requiring records to be provided during due diligence don’t necessarily guarantee that those records are complete or accurate to begin with.
Buyers should connect questionnaires, inspection reports, known defects, repair histories, and code notices to the contract provisions on which they intend to rely. If a representation is material for the purchase, the agreement should identify it directly and establish the available remedy.
General contractors, architects, consultants, and subcontractors who work during the design and construction phases also influence post-sale risk. Agreements should address:
- Record-retention responsibilities
- Correction obligations and warranty periods
- Notice procedures
- The assignment of warranties and claims
Closeout files should include testing and commissioning records, building envelope inspection reports, product warranties, and documentation of completed repairs.
Owners should also consider whether surety-backed protection is appropriate for building systems that could fail after occupancy. A101®, A201®, and A313™ can support a coordinated post-construction warranty strategy when properly selected and completed for the project.
Buyers need a practical plan for investigating defects, reviewing insurance coverage, enforcing warranties, and obtaining the records needed to diagnose a failure. They should also consider whether the acquisition budget includes adequate reserves for repairs.
Plan for Defects That Surface Later
AIA Contract Documents (ACD) explains how coordinated warranty documents can extend protection beyond construction and support long-term asset planning.