Skip to main content

Learn Resources – ACD

How the Texas Economic Loss Rule Makes Construction Delay Risk a Contract Issue

Recovery for damages can get complicated when they’re caused by a party you don’t have a contract with. When contract claims aren’t available, some assume that tort claims will be. But that’s not always the case. For example, in ESI Incorporated of Tennessee v. Orion Engineered Carbons, LLC, the Texas Business Court treated the alleged delay costs as economic risks, which should have been addressed in the contract. Accordingly, the court rejected the related tort claims under the Texas economic loss rule.

The message for architecture, engineering, and construction teams is straightforward: Define third-party responsibilities before work begins. A court may not use tort law to fill a remedy gap left by the contract chain, and special consideration should be given to the project state’s economic loss rule when considering what claims will be available.

This seems especially important to consider when you’re hired by the owner, but others’ work outside of your contract chain will impact your performance (like when a general contractor has to contend with separate contractors, vendors outside of their contract chain, and owners performing work).

Late Deliveries Exposed a Contract Gap

ESI entered an engineering, procurement, and construction agreement with Orion, the project owner, for emissions-control systems. The owner separately hired a vendor, Redecam, to supply system components. As a result, ESI’s performance depended, in part, on a third party. It did not end well. The delivery of key components was seriously delayed. As a result, ESI fell behind on its work, which resulted in a compressed timeline and caused over $10M in additional costs to ESI. ESI filed suit to recover those costs.

As part of its action, ESI sued Redecam for negligent misrepresentation and constructive fraud. It claimed that it had relied on Redecam’s timing information when pricing and scheduling the work, and Redecam’s failures caused ESI’s losses. Redecam filed for summary judgment on the ground that it had no relationship with ESI and shouldn’t be responsible.

The court agreed with Redecam, ruling that Texas’ Economic Loss Rule prevented ESI’s claims. The contractor only sought economic losses related to its performance under its agreement with the owner, and the court concluded that the agreement could have provided contractual protection against those risks (such as the A201® use of separate contractor provisions). The parties’ failure to account for a separate vendor’s impact shouldn’t result in tort liability for that vendor. The court also found that months of commercial collaboration between the parties didn’t create the special relationship required to support ESI’s constructive fraud claim against Redecam.

What is the Texas Economic Loss Rule?

Economic loss doctrines help create the boundary between contract law and tort law. Across the country, when a purely economic injury occurs, most states limit availability of torts under their state-specific economic loss rules. If the injury could have or should have been contemplated in a contract, courts may invoke the applicable economic loss rule to keep disputes in their appropriate lanes, depending on the jurisdiction and circumstances.

Texas follows the majority rule and keeps with most states: If the injury is purely economic, tort claims are likely not appropriate. Learn more about the Economic Loss Rule in Texas.

The Contract Should Account for Separate Contractors, When Present

As this case shows, additional legal claims won’t always be available when your contract leaves a liability gap.

If the general contractor is not in charge of all work on the project site, it’s important that they call out what happens when others’ work impacts their ability to timely perform their work. Knock-on effects, like damage to the contractor’s work, should be accounted for too. That’s true regardless of whether the owner has hired a separate contractor, supplier, or vendor, or if the owner is performing some work themselves.

Across the contract family, the parties should coordinate:

  • Delivery milestones and access dates
  • Authority to issue and rely on schedule information
  • Notice and documentation requirements
  • Acceleration and delay remedies
  • Upstream and downstream rights arising from the same event

Inconsistent flow-down provisions can make one party responsible for meeting a deadline while another controls the information, access, or equipment needed to meet it.

Maintain Alignment During Construction

Responsibility should remain clear throughout project performance. Procurement logs, delivery forecasts, schedule updates, requests for information, and impact notices should identify the applicable agreement, responsible party, and requested relief.

A well-maintained project record can help the team respond before a delay escalates. It can also support the available contract remedy if the parties can’t resolve the issue in the field.

Pro Tip Attach a responsibility matrix for owner-furnished equipment and third-party deliverables. Connect each critical date to a responsible party, notice process, and contractual remedy.

Address Delay Before Work Begins

AIA Contract Documents (ACD) explain how notice requirements, time extensions, claims procedures, and coordinated agreements can help project teams manage construction delay risk.

Disclaimer: The information contained in this article is for general informational purposes only, and the views contained herein are the author’s own. It is not legal advice or legal opinion; it does not create any attorney-client relationship; and it may not be used to indicate any intent or to inform any interpretation of ACD’s documents or services, which the AIA Documents Committee separately creates. If you need advice, seek the help of an attorney or other qualified professional who can help you make decisions based on the specifics of your situation.