A building can look finished from the parking lot and still be weeks away from closeout. Open changes, punch list work, missing turnover documents, and unreconciled retainage can stall a project right when everyone is trying to wrap up before the holidays.
In the AIA Contract Documents (ACD) webinar “Close Out Your Projects Right: 4 Steps to Finish the Year Strong,” an owner’s representative, a general contractor, and a subcontractor walked through one project’s final stretch from their own seats. Their construction closeout best practices came back to the same idea: when everyone knows what’s open, who owns it, and what’s required, the last few yards move faster. The panel included:
- Tara Cristel, co-owner of Total Glass, LLC, a glass and glazing subcontractor near St. Louis, and founder of The Subcontractor Project. Tara represents the subcontractor POV.
- Lauren Gibbs, CEO and owner of Gibbs Construction, a commercial building contractor in New Orleans. Lauren represents the contractor POV.
- Christopher Lasky, president of The Lasky Group in Pittsburgh and a member of the AIA Contract Documents Committee. Christopher represents the owner’s POV.
- Matt Viator, assistant general counsel at ACD (moderator).
Here are the four steps they covered, and what each party needs to finish strong.
Watch the Webinar Replay
Quick Reference Guide: Where Closeout Stalls and What Helps
| If closeout is stuck on… | Start here |
| Unresolved changes | Keep a shared change log and review it monthly |
| Unclear substantial completion | Walk the site together and agree on acceptable finish |
| Missing turnover documents | Track warranties and manuals on the submittal schedule |
| Late lien waivers | Request them as each vendor is paid |
| Retainage and final payment | Share payment status with every tier |
1. Reconcile Outstanding Changes Before the Final Push
Changes happen on every project. The problem is discovering them at the end.
Owners want predictability. An owner who knows their exposure throughout the job can plan for it. A wave of surprise changes at closeout makes the owner dig in.
“You don’t want to be sitting around at the end of the project trying to figure out what changes and what value they are.”
Christopher Lasky
For contractors, there may be a gap between contract language and reality. Lauren shared that work often proceeds before a change order is executed because it’s cheaper and faster for the project, and that takes trust. Her team logs open issues and asks subcontractors every month for unresolved claims. Christopher added a second benefit: putting a potential change in front of the architect and owner early can surface a better, cheaper solution.
Tara described the subcontractor’s side. Field crews sometimes must pivot the same day, so the change happens before the paperwork exists. Her advice:
- Document every change, including revised drawings, vendor pricing, and emails.
- Pick one communication channel for change orders and follow every phone call with an email that confirms what was decided.
- Make one person responsible for tracking change orders and review open items with your team monthly or twice a month.
Matt added the legal view: know who has authority to approve changes and put the approval in writing with a G701® – Change Order or, when the parties haven’t agreed on terms, a G714® – Construction Change Directive. The difference between a change order and a construction change directive matters most when price or time is still in dispute. Matt shared that communication is not an activity; it’s a result.
2. Confirm What Completion Requires
Christopher explained that contracts typically define substantial completion as the point when the owner can use the project for its intended purpose, even if punch list work remains. That milestone matters because it can start warranties and reduce retention. The difference between substantial completion and final completion should be clear to everyone before the final walkthrough, along with how it will be documented, such as on a G704® – Certificate of Substantial Completion.
He also recommended a walkthrough early enough to show the contractor and trades what an acceptable level of finish looks like.
“Then they have a baseline to go from to finish the project.”
Christopher Lasky
Lauren noted that substantial completion looks different on almost every job. A funding deadline might push for it while the punch list is still long. Another owner may be in no hurry because its current lease runs six more months. Reading those pressure points helps the contractor plan how the punch list will be evaluated. She also flagged the insurance handoff, from builder’s risk coverage during construction to the owner’s property insurance.
For subcontractors, Tara said this stage is mostly about paperwork:
- Request lien waivers from vendors as soon as you pay them, then save them until they’re requested.
- File warranties in the project folder as they arrive with vendor invoices.
- If your insurance renews in January, send the updated certificate of insurance before year-end.
- Finish your punch list items, tell the GC when they’re done, and talk openly about any item you don’t believe is yours.
3. Finish the Work and Assemble the Records
“Don’t trust someone else’s eyes.”
Lauren Gibbs
That’s Lauren’s first rule for the punch list. It isn’t about integrity. A sub may fix the scratch it saw rather than the one the architect saw, or fix it and leave drywall dust on the carpet. Her team checks every item in person, even its own crews’ work, before reporting it complete. Telling a design team something is done when it isn’t can cost credibility.
She also pushed back on the idea of a project with no punch list. However strong the quality control is, a final punch list process is still needed, even if it only turns up three items.
Subcontractors need early notice, according to Tara. Same-day document requests are hard for smaller offices to meet, and a concern spotted months before closeout gives the sub time to fix it. She recalled a project manager who called after a walkthrough to flag a likely issue long before the end of the job, which gave her team time to work out a solution.
Christopher pointed to an often-overlooked tool: the submittal schedule. Warranties, safety data sheets, and operating manuals belong on it. If equipment is installed and running months before substantial completion, there’s no reason to wait to submit those documents. Spacing them out avoids a document dump and gives the architect time to review them.
How To Avoid Multiple Punch Lists
When an attendee asked how to avoid separate punch lists from the owner, architect, and engineer, both Lauren and Christopher said to settle the process before the walkthroughs start:
- Agree on who walks the project, when, and who covers each room.
- Ask the owner to name one representative, rather than having every occupant punch their own space.
- Have the contractor start the list, and the architect add to it, with owner items routed through the architect.
- Agree on the quality standards in the contract documents and industry standards, so expectations stay realistic.
Christopher also warned that after substantial completion, movers and occupants can damage finished work. Clear expectations help separate true punch list items from new wear and tear.
4. Clear the Path to Final Payment
For most subcontractors, final payment means retainage. Tara said the biggest frustration at the end of the payment chain is silence. Subs often don’t hear when a pay application has been accepted, submitted to the owner, or paid.
“I think subs generally are willing to be a little bit more patient if they’re part of the conversation.”
Tara Cristel
Lauren called final payment the owner’s last tool to ensure satisfaction, which makes relationships and knowing the rules especially important. A warranty item can hold up final completion. She encouraged contractors to understand their state’s prompt payment laws, noting that Louisiana recently strengthened its requirements, and their lien rights. Matt added that lien deadlines vary by state, with some running from substantial completion and others from final completion, so know when the clock starts.
From the owner’s side, Christopher said final payment should be straightforward if the team has kept up with paperwork, including conditional final lien releases. Unless the owner is an institution or a public agency, a lender is often funding much of the project and may have its own requirements for releasing the final check. Owners should share those early.
The final payment package often includes a G702® – Application and Certificate for Payment, G706® – Contractor’s Affidavit of Payment of Debts and Claims, G706A® – Contractor’s Affidavit of Release of Liens, and, on bonded projects, G707™ – Consent of Surety to Final Payment. Confirm with the owner which documents the contract and lender require.
One Action Each Panelist Would Take
Matt asked each panelist for the single action that most prevents year-end delays:
- Christopher: Work from a shared, web-based project management platform so schedules, submittals, and records live in one place everyone can see.
- Lauren: Read the contract and reread it at the end. “If you’re going to break the rules, you better know the rules you’re breaking.”
- Tara: Get your punch list done.
What This Means for Your Year-End Closeout
Every panelist returned to communication, but in practical terms: a log everyone can see, one channel for changes, a walkthrough that sets expectations, records collected as the job moves, and payment status shared with every tier. These construction closeout best practices don’t remove the last-minute push, but they make it smaller. For a deeper look at the closeout process and documents, explore contract closeout lessons and best practices.
Watch Close Out Your Projects Right: 4 Steps to Finish the Year Strong
Hear the owner, general contractor, and subcontractor perspectives in full, including the attendee questions on lien waivers, punch lists, and requests for information.
Put These Steps into Practice
ACD offers hundreds of coordinated documents for managing changes, completion, and payment, plus AI tools built for construction.
Frequently Asked Questions
Substantial completion is typically when the owner can use the project for its intended purpose, even if punch list work remains. Final completion comes after the remaining work, documents, and requirements are finished and final payment can be processed.
Under many contracts, the contractor prepares the list first, and the architect adds to it. In practice, the architect often creates its own list, so agree on the process before walkthroughs begin.
Collect them throughout the project, as you pay each vendor, and keep them in a dedicated project folder. Waiting until closeout can delay everyone, especially around the holidays. These lien waiver best practices also apply to monthly pay applications.
Subcontracts often bind the sub to the prime contract’s terms. Christopher noted that AIA owner-contractor documents require those terms to flow down to subcontracts, such as an A401® – Agreement Between Contractor and Subcontractor. Without seeing the prime contract, it’s hard to comply with it.
A request for information, such as a G716™ – Request for Information (RFI), documents the question and starts the response clock. Christopher recommended a confirming RFI: discuss the field issue in the project meeting, agree on a solution, then submit an RFI that records it. The architect may also issue a G710™ – Architect’s Supplemental Instructions to clarify the design.